Framework · free to use

Should you build it or buy it?

When every workflow has both a build path (custom AI tooling) and a buy path (vendor product), the decision framework matters more than the technology. This is the decision tree we use with B2B clients to choose between building, buying, or a hybrid approach.

By Bill Colbert · Founder, Treetop Growth Strategy
Published May 2026 · More from the library
The four-question decision tree

Run each candidate workflow through these

  1. Is the workflow core to your competitive advantage? If yes → lean build (or build a thin layer on top of bought infrastructure). If no → lean buy.
  2. Does a good vendor product exist? Run a real pilot with 2-3 options. If yes → buy. If no but the workflow is core → build. If no and the workflow is not core → defer.
  3. Do you have the engineering capacity? Building real AI tooling requires sustained engineering (not just a one-off). If you do not have at least one engineer who can own this for 12+ months → buy.
  4. Will the workflow change frequently? If yes → favor vendor products (they absorb the change cost). If no, and you have the engineering → build can be the right call.
When to build

Three common build-justified situations

1. It is genuinely your edge

If your competitive advantage depends on a specific AI capability — pricing optimization unique to your data, a recommendation engine on proprietary signals — build it. Vendors will commoditize anything generic, but they cannot replicate your data.

2. Vendor tools cannot reach the integration depth you need

Some workflows touch so many systems (CRM + ERP + data warehouse + custom app) that no vendor can integrate deeply enough without custom work. In those cases, build the integration layer yourself even if you use vendor AI underneath.

3. Scale economics flip the math

At very high volume, per-token vendor pricing can exceed the cost of running your own deployment of an open-weight model. Most $5M-$50M companies are nowhere near this threshold; if you are, you know.

When to buy

Three common buy-justified situations

1. It is a horizontal capability

Meeting transcription, calendar scheduling, email triage, contract review — these are horizontal capabilities that thousands of companies need. Vendors will be better at them than you can be. Buy.

2. Speed matters more than fit

If you need it working in 30 days, you cannot build it. Vendor products ship in days. Building takes months. For most operational improvements, that gap is decisive.

3. The workflow will evolve and you cannot keep up

If the underlying model improvements would force you to rebuild every 6 months, let the vendor absorb that work.

Hybrid

The most common right answer

For mid-market B2B, the most common pattern is hybrid: buy the AI infrastructure, build the thin layer on top that captures your unique workflow.

Concrete example: buy Claude Team or Enterprise (do not build your own LLM). Build a Project loaded with your specific knowledge, your specific system prompt, your specific workflow. The total build cost is small (days, not months) and the differentiation comes from your data, your prompts, and your workflow design — not from the model.

Almost every successful AI deployment in the $5M-$50M segment we have seen is hybrid. "Build" and "buy" as polar opposites is a 2015 framing. The 2026 framing is "which layers do you buy, which do you customize."

Cost comparison

What each option really costs

OptionYear 1 costYear 2-3 ongoingWhen it fits
Buy (vendor SaaS)\$20K-\$80K typicalRenewals + expansionHorizontal workflow, urgency, no engineering capacity
Hybrid (LLM platform + your config)\$10K-\$50K (platform + Treetop-style implementation)Platform fees + occasional refreshMost B2B workflows
Build (custom on top of API or open weights)\$150K-\$600K + engineering FTESustained engineeringTruly core capability, sufficient scale, engineering team
Related

Related frameworks & reading

Want a roadmap built for your business?
The $1,500 AI Audit produces a written, prioritized roadmap in 5 business days.
Book the AI Audit → Take the Gap Assessment